National Center for Policy Analysis





HOME ABOUT THE NCPA SUPPORT DEBATE CENTRAL

Debate Central

Templeton Freedom Prize
Criticisms of Security Council : Not An Impartial Arbiter

  • Dictators and Double Standards Redux -- Leave it to a UN official to compare a liberal democracy to every run of the mill, self-appointed lifetime tyrant. True, there are no good or bad nuclear weapons, for they are just things. But there are most certainly good or bad forms of government, which is why people should worry when the head of the international nuclear watchdog deflects scrutiny away from the Ayatollah's nuclear program in favor of the always-popular cause of bashing the Bush administration. (Added: 18-May-2004 Hits: 110 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
  • Final Arbiter? -- The idea that legitimacy flows from the UN implies that the UN exists on a higher plane than that of the nation-state itself. But, of course, this is simply not true. The UN is a creature of the nation-state. It is a diplomatic construct, not some form of super-legislature or governing body. (Added: 18-May-2004 Hits: 118 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
  • One UN Resolution Too Many -- The UN ideal still inspires many millions of people around the world. I don't happen to share the ideal myself, but I can understand and respect it. But even believers in an ideal have to admit that ideals can be abused for selfish purposes--and they ought very seriously to ask themselves whether that abuse is not precisely what is occurring now at the United Nations. (Added: 17-May-2004 Hits: 112 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
  • Order Plus Liberty -- It's folly to trust the United Nations with nation building. Its record elsewhere - for example in Cambodia, Haiti, Rwanda, Bosnia, and Kosovo - is shameful. This is an organization whose Human Rights Commission, including its chair, boasts six countries from Freedom House's list of the world's most repressive regimes. Clearly the U.N. is morally bankrupt. Let's stop pretending its blessing confers any moral legitimacy. (Added: 18-May-2004 Hits: 87 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
  • Playing UN "Survivor" -- Survivor is a perfect microcosm for the self-destructive nature of the recently much ballyhooed foreign-policy principle that states that only the approval of others can grant a nation’s actions moral virtue – the principle of 'multilateralism.' 'Multilateralism' is based on the ethics of altruism - preaching sacrifice as the supreme virtue, and self-interest as the lowest vice. (Added: 18-May-2004 Hits: 81 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
  • The United Nations Against Individual Rights -- The UN's true purpose is to give Third World bullies a venue for grandstanding, to harangue Western democracies, to ensure that the world's cruelest rulers escape condemnation, and, of course, to bash Israel. There's nothing in that agenda to disqualify Libya. Or, for that matter, Vietnam, Saudi Arabia, China, Syria, Sudan, or Zimbabwe -- each a notorious human-rights violator and each a commission member in good standing (Added: 18-May-2004 Hits: 118 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
  • The United Nations: A Criminal Organization -- The United Nations is not an instrument for guarding the peace, but a criminal enterprise founded to condemn the good, and to sanction the evil. Articles are surfacing and pundits are pondering, questioning the future of the UN. To sidestep the obvious; that the UN utterly failed to have even a hint of influence during the resulting overthrow of Saddam, voices are beginning to suggest the word "reform" to make it more "workable." (Added: 18-May-2004 Hits: 130 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
  • UN Confidence Games -- American support for tough action abroad rises when backed by the United Nations. And international support soars when gaining UN approval. Why? (Added: 18-May-2004 Hits: 70 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
  • UN Dysfunctional by Design -- There is a good reason it is difficult to take the United Nations seriously: It is dysfunctional by design. It is cumbersome, undemocratic, and ineffective. The UN is to the world what Brussels is to the EU: A creeping supranational bureaucracy that supercedes national sovereignty in defense of what a few unscientific elites consider "the greater good". Whatever nine of the fifteen members of he security council decide becomes "international law". (Added: 18-May-2004 Hits: 139 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
  • World's Most Elaborate Insurance Policy -- The UN props up despots, lending them legitimacy, and waging PR campaigns on their behalf. In their zero-sum worldview, wealth is a sign of guilt, not progress. (Added: 18-May-2004 Hits: 76 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It


Add Link | Modify Link | What's New | What's Cool | Top Rated | Random Link | Search
The NCPA is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit public policy organization. We depend entirely on the financial support of individuals, corporations and foundations that believe in private sector solutions to public policy problems.

12770 Coit Rd., Suite 800 - Dallas, TX 75251-1339 Phone 972/386-6272 - Fax 972/386-0924
601 Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Suite 900 South Building, Washington, DC 2004 Phone Phone 202/220-3082 - Fax 202/220-3096
Copyright © 2003 National Center for Policy Analysis All rights reserved - Privacy Policy